Mike & Nick & Nick & Alice

James Marsden

Quick Draw Mike

Vince Vaughn

Future Nick / Present Nick

Eiza González

Alice

Keith David

Sosa

Jimmy Tatro

Jimmy Boy

Stephen Root

Chet

Lewis Tan

Roid Rage Ryan

Dolph Lundgren

The Barron

Ben Schwartz

Symon

Arturo Castro

Dumbass Tony

Emily Hampshire

Sam

Paul Cheng

Scary Gangster #1

Maxime Savaria

Scary Gangster #2

Sara Alicia Garcia

Roid Rage Ryan's Wife

Mackenzee Cullen

Women #1 Who Gives Mike The Look

Kaitlyn Bacon

Woman #2 Who Gives Mike The Look

Stanlee Arches

Hotel Employee

Tristan Carlucci

Drunk Mobster

David Tomlinson

Stoic Male Bartender

Dylan Playfair

Stoned Cashier

Aaron Hughes

Cop #2

Dayleigh Nelson

Nick Acting Double

Ella Ballentine

Marceline

Brett Taylor

Wedding Dancer #1